WHIRLYGIG 2” MINI TRICOPTER 2S V1

By 1Smug_Bastard on May 17, 2019

12  481  15

For when the weather outside is bad, I've always wanted a small Tricopter capable of indoor flight. Unfortunately something like this doesn't exist on the market so I've taken up the challenge of making my own. After performing all the needed measurements from the equipment currently on hand. I sat down and designed the Whirlygig exclusively using Fusion 360.

https://www.thingiverse.com/thing:3597694

Photos

Discussion

Sign in to comment

fovea   May 18, 2019  

very nice, please add more pctures of the beauty. a dvr to see flightcaracteristic of a nanotricopter would be very nice

Show 4 more comments
1Smug_Bastard   May 21, 2019 
1

Bicopters are a mixed bag simply because they control flight by managing their Center of Gravity. (CG) Pitching the motors ahead induces the CG forward and thus provides forward flight. While this sounds cool, you have to keep in mind that the Bicopter is by its very nature an unstable craft. This is compounded by the fact that Servos are not especially fast at compensating for oscillations and at worst tend to overcompensate inducing further oscillations. Only way to tune a Bicopter is to undertune the Yaw and keeping the Yaw D-Term at ZERO. Pitch should always have the strongest PID values because of it's critical roll in managing the Bicopters CG. While Roll should be moderately tuned to help prevent oscillations.

To do what your wanting would require that the props have clearance from the wings and that the battery is mounted way under the frame to keep the CG down low . The wings may or maynot work well simply because the copters flight controller is always expecting to always provide lift using the motors. Thus wings add a dimension that the Copters mixer may not be able to compesate for. IMO it would be advisable to use a custom mixer or one that allows you to toggle between Copter and Fixed-Wing modes of flight. I know this will work as it's been done but to be honnest there's no clear advantage to doing so other then having VTOL. For a wing its not going to fly great and for a bicopter it can be a too unstable. In the end this will be more of a novelty craft and not exactly the best of both worlds.

fovea   May 21, 2019 

thanks alot for your answer. i still try to understand everything. thank you for the shared honnest thougts about. thanks alot you take the time for this informative answer.

to explain my motivation, if you like to understand. it comes from this brushed rudderless quadroplane, very fastinating for me: https://rotorbuilds.com/builds/16433
and it comes from the “eachine e500“ (it would have the mixersettings i will need, i beleive) were my knowledge is in the end of understanding what advantages a rudder should have in comparison to a “motor conected to a servo„.
this is where my motivations come from and other part is i like to build... with the parts i have.

thank you very much for the pid infos, this will be a big help.

i start a mockup as a build log, if you like to see were i am in my process - but i have to update with the knowledge earn from you (when i understand your answer completly); https://rotorbuilds.com/builds/18067

StickyRice   May 18, 2019  

omg how did you connect servo to the controller?? ive been wanting to do that too but i have no idea. Hope it flies well!!

1Smug_Bastard   May 19, 2019 
1

Pretty easy really...

Pos / Neg connected to Vbat (2S Lipo) with the singnal wire connected to a motor pad on the Flight Controller. In my case this was S1 and then set to PWM @ 330Hz within the firmware. Motors 1-3 were connected to motor-pads S2 - S4 respectively and use dShot-600. Keep in mind that I’m using dRonin and not Betaflight. This way i can Auto-Tune the PID’s, thus having a better overall flight experiance for such a little copter.

StickyRice   May 21, 2019 

THANK YOU!! ive been thinking about doing some projects (not drones) that utilizes an fc and servos and motors.

1Smug_Bastard   May 21, 2019 
1

No worries.
I do allot of this stuff... I've build 3-4 Tricopters, 1 bicopter and a few quads.

IcarusIX   May 17, 2019  
1

Yessss my guy, micro tri ftw! 1) does it work reliably/smoothly? 2) plan on lightening it up a little? he seems to be a bit of a chunky lad :)

1Smug_Bastard   May 18, 2019 
2

Made a lighter, less chunky version of the Whirlygig: https://www.thingiverse.com/thing:3639210

1Smug_Bastard   May 17, 2019  
1

@IcarusIX

Without the Camera and Top, i was able to get the weight down to 60g. This allowed for 4 minutes of acro flight and yes its pretty smooth on dRonin. Was chasing my son around the house with it.

Beta flight on the otherhand, itsnt so great for Tricopters. ..

From a post I made earlier on Reddit (https://www.reddit.com/r/Multicopter/comments/bnobwu/discussion_semilong_range_tricopter_vs_semilr/en8yj8u/)

"Tricopters using Betaflight dont calibrate the Tilt-Mechanism nor does it account for the counter torque very well. (Hence the wag) This is why Davids Tri’s are all using a special build of dRonin called TriRonin. Not only does this calibrate the Tail, it Autotunes the PID’s and uses advanced algorithms to manage the tail torque. Furthermore, Tri’s dont fly well with very high PID’s values or any Yaw D-Term. In my experiance a moderate tune works best, while specifically focusing / boosting Pitch and Roll terms. Then set the Yaw P & I only as high as needed to achive the performance your looking for."

Beyond all that, I'm considering if it would be worth it to refine the build, going for lighter parts (Cam / VTX / No PDB) or to just scale up to a 3" Tri using the same hardware, just larger motors / props. Basic idea being is that this would increase lifting capacity and allow for 4S Lipo's to boot.

Guides & Reviews

3 2,128  9
Sep 18, 2019

When the FatShark HDOs hit the market in 2018 the FPV community rejoiced for the new Sony OLED displays. While they lacked further upgrades like an updated DVR and power button they were still a market success. With the 2019 announcement of the Orqa FPV.One the community finally had a potential HDO killer on the horizon. With only weeks before the release of the Orqa FPV.One Skyzone came out of left..

Read more
Aug 21, 2019

Want to learn how to build an FPV rig? This guide will walk you through your first FPV freestyle build. These parts were hand-picked to balance cost and maximize performance. The TBS Source One is a popular frame for it's low cost, high quality carbon fiber. It's easy to work with and provides more than enough space for your electronics. We've got a 32bit 4-in-1 ESC to bring you the smoothest flights..

Read more